
A sign outside the Marcus Garvey Garden Apartments. The building’s two elevators have been intermittently out of service, sometimes for months at a time. 
Vivian
Phillips, a resident at the Marcus Garvey Garden Apartments in Roxbury,
poses for a photo in her home, Oct. 31. Residents of the building,
which serves elderly and disabled residents, have reported concerns
about persistent elevator outages that they say have impacted their
ability to get around.
When the elevator doors at Marcus Garvey Garden Apartments stay shut, so do many residents’ front doors. Inside the Roxbury building for elderly and disabled tenants, months of elevator outages have left people stranded, anxious and wondering when — or if — help is coming.
The building has two elevators for residents to use. Of those, the rear elevator has not been working for over two months, to date.
During the summer, the front elevator was out from early July through early August.
“This is a senior building with people with walkers and wheelchairs,” said resident Vivian Phillips. “It doesn’t make any sense.”
Raphaela Thomas, another resident, said she has even witnessed first responders carry out elderly residents on stretchers during instances when both elevators were down.
Eva Postell, another longtime resident of the building, said that when the front elevator goes down, she has to walk from her apartment toward the front of the building all the way to the back one. With COPD and breathing problems, the trip down the building’s long corridors leaves her winded and having to pause halfway.
“We depend on the elevators,” she said.
An elevator outage can also mean that residents who use walkers have to carry them — generally with assistance — down the stairs.
Phillips said that to attend doctor appointments, she would need to get assistance to walk down the steps and wait outside, sometimes in the rain.
Matt
Bruker, president of SHP Management Corporation, the Maine-based
company that manages the Marcus Garvey Garden Apartments, said the
company has been working with its elevator contractor, design engineers
and Mass Housing to address the outages.
He
said that the age of the elevators can mean it takes a long time to
obtain parts. SHP is currently waiting for an update from the elevator
contractor on the parts needed to make near-term repairs to the rear
elevator.
State Rep.
Chynah Tyler, whose district includes Marcus Garvey Garden Apartments,
said she has been tracking the elevator outages closely. She first
noticed there was a problem when she visited the building to do a
wellness check with a resident and noticed the elevator was down; a few
days later, the elevator was still out.
Tyler
said she has been working with SHP and understands the limited
availability of parts and elevator technicians, but said she sees a need
to make sure the process keeps moving.
“Urgency is important when you’re talking about accessibility,” Tyler said.
The
problems with the elevators have been ongoing. Phillips said they’ve
been facing challenges at least since she moved into the Marcus Garvey
Apartments eight years ago, though the recent outages have been the
worst yet.
For the past couple of years, she said she remembers the
elevators going out two or three times per year. Postell said those
outages would generally last a matter of days to a week.
In her mind, Phillips said the ideal situation is for the aging elevators to simply be replaced.
She
said she’d like to see ramps installed from the terrace-level entrance
at the building’s second floor — where the back elevator drops off — to
help residents get down to street level in instances if the front
elevator is out.
Currently,
stairs lead down from the second-floor entrance, one level up because
of the building’s place on a hillside to the street level, but without
the elevator, the only way to get down with a walker or wheelchair is to
follow the driveway out to the street and around to the front.
Phillips said she has found drivers often don’t come up the driveway.
Brucker
said a long-term solution to the elevator outages is in the works. He
said SHP recently received approval of a request to modernize and update
the rear elevator, which should stabilize and improve its performance.
But the timeline for that project is an extended one — an estimated
seven and a half to 10 months design, bid, order and perform the work.
In an email, Brucker called it “quite a large undertaking.”
Residents said the repair
process — and the long timeline it has brought — has been poorly
communicated and shrouded in confusion. Phillips said that when she has
asked for information, she’s been given a “runaround” or “non-answers,”
with building management unclear about when things will actually be
fixed.
Thomas said
when she had asked for information about the elevators, the building’s
management wasn’t able to give a proper answer about the process or the
delays.
Postell, too, said that the situation has left her confused.
“I don’t understand why the elevators are taking so long to get fixed,” Postell said. “I have no clue.”
As
of Oct. 31, a memo hanging in the working front elevator said the rear
elevator had been out since Aug. 26, and that a repair time would be
posted to the elevators once available. That memo was dated Sept. 4.
Brucker
said SHP Management recently implemented a weekly update regarding the
elevators, but that often the update is that there is no news. The
onsite management team will be scheduling an in-person resident meeting
this month to discuss overall developments with the property and hear
residents’ questions and concerns.
He said those meetings, moving forward, should occur quarterly.
But
in the meantime, residents said they feel like poor communication
around the elevator outages, as well as other issues in the building,
are an indicator that management doesn’t care about the people who live
there.
“I just feel like they don’t really hear out the tenants,” Thomas said. “It’s more on their terms.”