Jim Hightower is on vacation this week.
The
chorus of loud demands for Senator Al Franken’s resignation began from
the moment that Leeann Tweeden accused him of sexual harassment. Those
calls intensified after three more women – two of them anonymous – said
the Minnesota Democrat had touched them inappropriately. They haven’t
subsided yet.
Although
not all the facts are clear, Franken apologized immediately. Since
then, he has admitted that his conduct on some occasions had fallen
short of the respect for women he has always professed.
“I let a lot of people down,” the former comedian told the Minneapolis Star-Tribune in a contrite interview, vowing to win back the trust of his constituents.
To
say that Franken’s friends and associates are shocked is a profound
understatement. Here I must disclose that I’ve considered Al and his
wife, Franni, to be friends of our family for more than a decade, ever
since the days when I appeared regularly on his Air America radio show.
And I’m as stunned as anyone else, including his female colleagues at
“Saturday Night Live,” who have signed a letter supporting him. He was
funny and profane, but I never saw him behave with anything but
impeccable respect for everyone, male and female alike.
Even
if we had never become friends, I wouldn’t expect Franken to quit.
Anybody who saw him endure his first tough Senate race, or watched him
become one of the most effective Democrats in Washington,
knows he is no quitter. He has returned to work while the Senate Ethics
Committee pursues its investigation of his case.
Of
course, he can reconsider resignation, if and when Donald Trump resigns
– or at least stops disparaging and lying about the women he assaulted.
Or perhaps when Roy Moore, still on his way to the Senate, speaks one
honest word about the women who accuse him of luring, molesting and
assaulting them when they were still girls.
While
we await the truth from Trump and Moore, the Ethics Committee probe of
Franken will proceed, as it should, to assess the evidence with his full
cooperation. They should also examine the intriguing clues to a
right-wing campaign aimed at unseating Franken, which features Trump
dirty trickster Roger Stone, Russian bots and various unsavory figures
on the so-called alt-right.
They
hate Franken for exposing Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ lies about
Russia. But the well-earned anger of the Trumpsters is certainly no
reason for a Democratic senator to leave office.
Nor
is there any reason why a Democrat should be less entitled to due
process than a Republican like David Vitter or Bob Packwood, both former
senators who were subject to ethics probes over sexual misconduct.
Their cases are instructive now.
In
2007 Vitter, a far-right religious fraud from Louisiana, admitted that
he had solicited prostitutes. The Ethics Committee eventually dismissed
Vitter’s case, not because he didn’t commit a crime but because his
conduct occurred before he ran for the Senate, never resulted in
criminal charges and didn’t
involve misuse of Senate resources or staff. Packwood, a moderate
Republican from Oregon, was plausibly accused in 1992 of forcing himself
on dozens of women, including several who had lobbied him or worked on
his staff.
Three years
later an exhaustive probe by the Ethics Committee – then chaired by
Mitch McConnell, who is now the Senate majority leader – resulted in a
10,000-plus page record that included clear evidence of felonies. He
resigned before the Senate could vote to expel him (and became a
lobbyist).
If that
process was deemed correct and proper for a pair of miscreants like
Packwood and Vitter, it should be sufficient for Franken, whose offenses
are very minor by comparison. In the meantime, he need not depart the
Senate unless he no longer feels he can serve his country and his
constituents. He was duly elected to a second term, by a wide margin, so
the bar to his removal should be high – at least as high as for those
whose proven offenses were far worse.
Joe Conason served as the Manhattan Weekly’s executive editor from 1992 to 1997. He wrote a popular political column for the New York Observer from
1992 to 2011. Since 1998, he has also written a column that is among
the most widely read features on the internet magazine Salon.com. His
most recent book, Big Lies: The Right-Wing Propaganda Machine and How It Distorts the Truth (St. Martin’s Press, 2003), was a New York Times and Amazon.com bestseller.