How did alcoholism come to be seen as a disease rather than a sin? Social drinking has progressed from being seen by some as simply a sinful activity to our current understanding of chemical addiction as a treatable disorder. It’s been a long road, but we can say that the outlook for people with addiction is far improved over what it was even a decade ago.
If you think about it, even normal alcohol use is unsavory to some. Alcohol addiction (alcoholism) is something completely different from social drinking. Many people are still convinced that alcoholics are not sick, they’re just bad people getting worse by the day!
Let’s eavesdrop on two situations, or scenarios. They’re very different – in fact, essentially different – from one another, although to a casual observer, they may appear identical.
Scenario One: Normal, recreational drinkers go to a bar. They enter the barfully conscious
of their environment. They have one or two drinks, then they leave,
having experienced the diversion of having their mood elevated slightly
by moderate use of alcohol. For them, the emphasis is on socializing,
not drinking.
Scenario Two: In
contrast, seemingly normal, seemingly recreational drinkers go to a
bar. A casual observer might think they were seeing a normal drinker
entering the building to have some diversion, but let’s look at these
people more closely. These people enter the bar already partially
disoriented, “unplugged” from the reality around them, even before they
take the first drink of the evening. Addictive drinkers (alcoholics)
believe they can control their intake of alcohol. When they drink,
they’re triggered to want to drink more. Their emphasis is on drinking,
not socializing.
Much
of society has frowned on drinking in general and on addictive drinking
in particular. Just imagine the challenge and stigma both to people
affected with alcohol addiction and to those who would help them when
faced with such anger and, often, shaming.
Alcoholics
and those encountering them are unaware that an alcoholic isn’t and
never has been a recreational drinker. They don’t realize that the
alcoholic has a pre-existing problem, the roots of which are there, deep
in the brain, even before he
or she ever takes their first drink. The problem may only recently have
become detectable, but the vulnerability to develop it has been there
all along.
There’s
recreational drinking, and then there’s addiction. To a casual
observer, recreational drinking and addiction look alike at first, but
they have little in common. True social drinking is done by conscious
choice; it’s voluntary. Addictive drinking is involuntary.
Alcoholics
and other addicts are victims of a brain-based “domino effect,” in
which their ability to self-determine their voluntary behavior is
impaired. Since we know that craving alcohol isn’t normal, what brings
it about? Abnormal, out-of-control appetites created by genetics,
possibly trauma, and exposure to alcohol. At first, alcoholics resemble –
and think themselves to be – people out for entertainment, people who
can drink in moderation, making a conscious decision to do so. They
aren’t.
Over
time, alcoholics think themselves to be people willfully committing
sinful acts in spending and losing money, people who are too stupid or
selfish to see the need to drink in moderation or just stop. They
aren’t.
In due time, alcoholics think themselves to be people who are out of control of their behavior. They are.
If
I have a seizure and, in my flailing about, accidentally hit you, is
that a good thing? No. Is it a bad thing to deliberately hit someone?
Yes. Did I hit you voluntarily? No,
because at that moment, I had no ability not to flail about, and my
hitting you was an unfortunate accident. Later, when I come back to
myself, I’ll feel remorse.
A
seizure is the no-fault result of problems in the electrochemical
activity in parts of the brain. Seizure disorder produces potentially
dangerous, involuntary behavior. People with seizure disorder aren’t
being selfish or uncaring. However you describe it, it isn’t voluntary.
Likewise,
addiction is also the no-fault result of problems in the
electrochemical activity in other parts of the brain. Addictive
disorders also produce potentially dangerous involuntary behavior.
However you may describe it, it isn’t voluntary.
How
did alcoholism come to be seen as a disease rather than a sin?
Education. As clinicians we strive to educate others as broadly as we
can. Community education is one of the most important things we do. Why?
Because new information can change thinking, and changed thinking
alters how the person feels emotionally and how they respond to the
challenges imposed by recovery. They see themselves in a different
light, and, therefore, behave differently from before. They can become
responsible and now stand tall, knowing, as the saying goes, that
they’re “not bad people getting good, but sick people getting better by
the day!”
Kent Dean,
PhD, LAC, has been active in behavioral health counseling since 1975. He
is CADA’s (the Council on Alcoholism & Drug Abuse) director of
clinical development.