A
28 bus drives past a bus shelter with a new plant-covered roof. The
green roofs — the city installed 30 along the route — are expected to
bring more shade and cooling to Roxbury, Dorchester and Mattapan,
through which the buses drive, as well as collecting stormwater, over
the next three years. For riders of the number 28 bus, the journey will be a little cooler, especially on hot summer days, through a new city initiative installing plant-filled coverings — green roofs — on bus shelters along the route.
The shelters come as part of a push to increase green infrastructure — plant- and nature-based solutions to climate challenges — across the city.
“It’s a way that we can help introduce many benefits to cool our city, to help keep our streets free of flooding and overall increase quality of life,” said Zoe Davis, senior project manager for climate resilience with the city.
This month, through the project, the city announced the installation of new plant-filled roofs over the existing structures of 30 bus shelters along the 28 bus route, which cuts from Mattapan Station through Dorchester and Roxbury to Ruggles Station.
Davis said the city thinks the green-roof installation is one of the largest efforts of its kind — perhaps the largest — in the United States to date. (Similar or larger efforts are already underway in Europe).
City officials expect the retrofitted shelters to provide cooling in three different ways. In perhaps the most immediate, the green roofs now cover the glass roofs that are the default design for the shelters. The increased shade the roofs provide will cut down the heat community members feel through air temperature and direct sun exposure.
Increased greenery can also help to reduce heat island effects — where sunlight warms heat-absorbent materials like asphalt and concrete, which then retain that heat past midday and even into the night.
As
plants release water, they also cool an area. Through a process called
transpiration, water that has moved through a plant is released through
its leaves — effectively its version of sweating. The evaporating water
lowers temperatures around the plant.
Multiple benefits
These
cooling effects are supplemented by benefits relating to stormwater
retention. Davis said the 30 new roofs are estimated to capture about
1,500 gallons of water over the three years they’re slated to be in use —
and provide some new support and habitat for pollinators like bees,
birds and butterflies.
“We’re hitting a lot of co-benefits with this project,” she said.
The
city identified green roofs at bus shelters— along with other cooling
measures like fans and misting — as a “catalytic project” in its 2022
heat resilience plan.
Those
catalytic projects were intended to be a starting point, something the
city could do shortly after the report was released.
“The
goal here is for the heat plan to not only just be our framework, but
we’re looking to address some immediate impacts of extreme heat,” Davis
said. “One of the ways that we wanted to do this was looking at our
transportation infrastructure, addressing the fact that many commuters
don’t have shade when they’re going into work or wherever they’re
traveling.”
The effort
follows a pilot program from 10 years ago, run by Social Impact
Collaborative with Weston Nurseries, as is the current green roof
project. That one was more limited, and only ran over one summer, Davis
said, in large part due to complications around maintenance costs.
This time around,
maintenance was built into the contracts the city signed. That sort of
change is part of a push to make programs like this more effective and
sustainable in the long term as the city looks to expand its green
infrastructure offerings across the city.
For
example, the city has installed new rain gardens in Nubian Square. At
Harambee Park, along Blue Hill Avenue, they added a constructed wetland.
The South End’s Harrison Avenue has new permeable pavers that allow
more absorption of rain. Along New England Avenue in Dorchester, the
city dug bioswales — plant-filled trenches to collect and move
stormwater.
Regionally,
other efforts are focused on green infrastructure projects and pushes
to cool active transportation like walking, biking, and taking the bus.
In Boston, Davis has been involved with a few other projects involving green infrastructure, too.
She
has worked to support the city’s Roxbury Resilient Corridors project,
which includes new street trees and plantings to cool the area and
address stormwater concerns along Malcom X Boulevard, Warren Street and
Melnea Cass Boulevard.
She’s
also involved with an effort to “cap” part of Interstate 90 where it
cuts through downtown, cutting Chinatown off from the South End and the
Leather District.
Targeting affected communities
Through
it all, Davis said, the city’s priority is on parts of the city that
have long seen increased impacts from climate change.
“We
know that communities of color, among other socially vulnerable
populations within the city, have experienced a history of
disinvestment,” Davis said. “It has shaped the way that people
experience extreme heat through the built environment, the way that
policies have formed the built environment and the way that people are
able to access resources to stay cool.”
That
mindset is part of why the 28 bus route — which runs through three
different communities of color and census tracts that are exclusively
designated as environmental justice communities — was selected for the
green roofs. Davis said it was also chosen for its high ridership and
the fact that it’s one of the three bus routes made free through city
subsidies.
And she
said she hopes these 30 bus shelters won’t be the end of the effort in
the city, but that instead, the information gathered over the next three
years will help make the case that these should be part of the standard
design for bus shelters in the city.
“This
is sort of our test run to say, ‘Hey, we know that these work. They
work in similar climates across the globe,’ and trying to understand how
we may be able to implement these further in Boston,” Davis said.
Now
is the moment for that work, she said. The contract the city holds with
a vendor to manage its “street furniture” — things like bus shelters,
as well as benches and informational signs — is set to expire in 2026.
Currently, it is held by JCDecaux.
“There
really is an opportunity to ensure through procurement and through
contracting, that we’re really embedding climate resilience into our
street furniture,” Davis said.
A push for broader efforts
But
in some parts of the city, community members want to see green
infrastructure efforts come as part of more comprehensive strategies for
individual communities.
In
Grove Hall, Ed Gaskin, executive director of the area’s Main Streets
organization, has been an advocate for local green infrastructure
efforts like bolstering greenery in the medians along Blue Hill
Avenue.
In his eyes, projects like the work on the medians or the green roofs
on the bus shelters are a start, but don’t manage to get to the core of
the issue.
“Without an
overall plan, you just have a bunch of one-off stuff,” he said. “Oneoff
is better than nothing, but at the end of the day, the greening of the
bus shelters isn’t going to make that much of a difference.”
To
really address the area’s needs, he wants to see “green zone” audits
and analyses by a governmental entity — he envisions the state — to look
at the environmental needs and situation of a neighborhood to be able
to better divvy up funding and address issues.
“We
felt that there needed to be a more systematic way of looking at what
the needs in the community were from an environmental standpoint. Having
inventory of those needs and then being able to move forward …
understanding that a neighborhood like Grove Hall should be receive
higher priority than Nantucket.”
To
get at addressing those specific needs, Gaskin wrote proposed
legislation that was filed at the State House in March 2023. That bill
would have created a state process to establish “green zones,” areas
that would have a specific zonewide plan for how to address
environmental needs in the vicinity.
The
bill never received a hearing and wasn’t passed before the end of the
legislative session in July. Gaskin said he hopes to see the legislation
refiled in the next session.
At
the heart of it, for him, is an equity-rather-than-equality standpoint,
looking to prioritize neighborhoods like Grove Hall that tend to see
increased impacts and harms from environmental hazards.
A
report published in May by Gaskin’s Greater Grove Hall Main Streets
organization pointed to disparities in the presence of dark, impervious
surfaces that can increase heat island effects and limit stormwater
drainage, as well as more limited tree coverage and other greenery.
He
compared installing green infrastructure across the city to putting a
shirt through the wash — effective at an overall clean, but potentially
unable to appropriately address a specific spot where there’s a stain.
“If
you have a neighborhood like Grove Hall or something, and that’s the
spot, then it needs concentrated effort to get the stain out, not just
the same effort that the other neighborhood — the rest of the shirt —
needs,” he said.