Adults who are chronically lonely are at higher risk for strokes, according to new research from the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
The study, published June 24 in eClinicalMedicine, found that adults in the United States over 50 years old who were identified to be chronically lonely over a span of four years had a 56% higher risk of having a stroke compared to those who were consistently less lonely.
The study brings attention to a growing field of research on the broader health impacts of loneliness and social isolation, and expands understanding of the risk of loneliness over a longer term, said Yenee Soh, a research associate at the school, who worked on the study.
“Recognizing that loneliness has consequences beyond just the experience in itself and can have impacts on other physical health outcomes is quite a significant issue to consider, especially as we have an increasingly aging population, and loneliness is an increasingly problematic issue,” said Soh, who holds a doctor of science degree.
The study found that the elevated risk was not seen in adults over 50 who only were only identified as lonely at a single point during the four-year time period.
“This suggests to us that, in the short term, loneliness may not be put people at higher risk, but over time, if we don’t address it and loneliness becomes a chronic experience, there’s a potential, based on our study, that the risk is much higher for stroke,” Soh said.
That heightened likelihood of stroke
was correlated with chronic isolation is particularly notable, said
Andrew Steptoe, a professor of psychology and epidemiology at the
University College London, who was not affiliated with the study.
“A
single or one-off measure may be affected by transient factors on the
day of assessment, for example feeling lonely because you have had a row
with someone, or your loved ones happen to be away. But if individuals
report loneliness across a four-year period, this suggests that the
experience is long-lasting,” Steptoe said in an email.
For
older adults in Boston, the local landscape in some ways sets
individuals up for social isolation, said Jean DeMayo, director of
development and marketing at Little Brothers-Friends of the Elderly
Boston, a local nonprofit that runs programming to connect older adults
in public and affordable housing with younger volunteers to reduce
isolation.
According
to the American Community Survey, an annual data collection effort run
by the U.S. Census Bureau, nearly 35% of adults over 65 in Boston live
alone — nationally, that number is closer to 27%.
DeMayo
also pointed to older adults living below the poverty line or facing
language barriers, but said efforts like the programming Little
Brothers–Friends of the Elderly offers can help close gaps.
“Those
factors put them in an increased risk for loneliness and isolation,”
she said. “When we connect generations to one another, we find not only
health benefits from a physical standpoint, but mentally and emotionally
too.”
Even in
settings like senior housing complexes or senior centers, where Little
Brothers– Friends of the Elderly runs programming, older adults may not
have many social connections.
Stephanie
Hisman-Hou, program director at the organization, said that she’s heard
from participants that sometimes they don’t know anyone else in their
building before participating in a Little Brothers–Friends of the
Elderly event.
A loneliness epidemic
The
Harvard study comes as health professionals worldwide have identified
growing concerns around loneliness and social isolation across age
groups. Last year, the U.S. Surgeon General released an advisory
identifying loneliness and isolation as an epidemic — a move that Soh
called “pivotal.”
In
that advisory, Dr. Vivek Murthy, the surgeon general, identified
isolation and loneliness as a widespread concern across the United
States.
“Given
the profound consequences of loneliness and isolation, we have an
opportunity, and an obligation, to make the same investments in
addressing social connection that we have made in addressing tobacco
use, obesity and the addiction crisis,” he wrote in the advisory.
Other
prominent health groups, like the World Health Organization, have
identified loneliness and isolation as public health and policy issue in
need of action.
Steptoe
said he sees a large need for research and health efforts to focus on
loneliness and isolation, especially among aging populations.
“There
are many reasons why we should be concerned with loneliness at older
ages, including its effects on quality of life and mental health,” he
said. “What
this [work from Harvard] and similar studies show is that loneliness may
impact physical health as well.”
And
the impact goes beyond just middle-aged and older adults. According to a
Gallup poll released in October, nearly a quarter of individuals 15
years and older worldwide feel very or fairly lonely.
The
Surgeon General’s advisory also cited research that found prolonged
loneliness was connected to increased rates of depression among adults
as well as children and adolescents, and found that while older adults
are more likely to be socially isolated, young adults aged 18 to 24 are
almost twice as likely to report feeling lonely to those over 66.
More research is needed
But research in the field still has room to grow, Soh said.
Even
within the new Harvard study, the results only shed light on adults
over 50 in the United States — more research would be needed to consider
younger populations or those in other parts of the world, she said.
And
though the paper identified some pathways by which loneliness could
raise the risk of stroke in older adults, Steptoe said studies of this
type cannot definitively show that loneliness is the cause of the
strokes.
But work like
this raises new questions to better understand the impact loneliness
and isolation have on physical health, such as why some people can be
frequently isolated but don’t feel lonely while others may be “lonely in
a crowd,” or, if loneliness really is causing increased stroke risk,
what the pathway for that impact really is, Steptoe said.
Soh
said that question of mechanisms would be an important step forward in
the field, especially to make the results from studies like hers more
actionable.
“Ultimately,
if we want to intervene, because we perceive loneliness as a risk
factor, what are the interventions that people can do, and what does
that intervention address?” she said. “More study on whether
interventions are successful, at least short term and preferably in the
longer term, would also be important next research steps.”