President Obama said in his State of the Union speech, “We’ve already agreed to more than $2 trillion in cuts and savings.”
That was reassuring. The new budget he released this week promises $4 trillion in “deficit reduction” — about half in tax increases and half in spending cuts. But like most politicians, Obama misleads.
Cato Institute economist Dan Mitchell cut through the fog to get at the truth of the $2 trillion “cut.”
“We have a budget of, what, almost $4 trillion? So if we’re doing $2 trillion of cuts,” Mitchell said, “we’re cutting government in half. That sounds wonderful.”
But what the president was talking about is not even a cut. The politicians just agreed that over the next 10 years, instead of increasing spending by $9.48 trillion, they’d increase it by “just” $7.3 trillion. Calling that a “cut” is nonsense.
Mitchell
gave an analogy: “What if I came to you and said, ‘I’ve been on a diet
for the last month, and I’ve gained 10 pounds. Isn’t that great?’ You
would say: ‘Wait, what are you talking about? That’s insane.’ And I
said: ‘I was going to gain 15 pounds. I’ve only gained 10 pounds,
therefore my diet is successful.’” Democrats use this deceit when they
want more social spending. Republicans use it for military spending.
And the press buys it. The Washington Post has been writing about “draconian cuts.”
“The
politicians know this game,” Mitchell said. “The special interests know
this game. Everyone gets a bigger budget every year.... And we wind up,
sooner or later, being Greece.”
We are definitely on the road to bankruptcy.
“We
have maybe 10, 15 years’ advanced notice. And what’s frustrating is
that we’re not taking advantage of that, even as we see these other
countries collapsing into social chaos and disarray.”
Mitchell
points out that the politicians don’t even have to make actual cuts to
save the future. If they just slowed the growth of government to about 2
percent per year, the US economy could grow out of this mess. But the
politicians won’t do even that.
“Being
from the Cato Institute, I actually do want to cut spending. But if all
we’re trying to do is balance the budget over 10 years, which is sort
of the minimal thing that politicians keep saying we should do, if we
simply limit the growth of spending to 2 percent a year, which is about
the projected rate of inflation, we’ll have a balanced budget in
2022.... But instead, the politicians say, ‘Oh, we’ll have draconian and
savage budget cuts.’ ...They don’t want to put government on a diet,
even if that diet allows spending to grow 2 percent a year.”
They also continually mislead us about what their schemes will cost.
President
Bush said the war in Iraq would cost $50 billion to $60 billion. It
cost $800 billion. When Medicare Part A was created, the government said
it would cost $9 billion in 1990. It cost $67 billion. They said the
hiring of TSA airport security screeners would cost $100 million. Then
they spent $700 million. Yet the media report the estimates as if they
are realistic. Again and again, politicians get away with
underestimating the cost of their programs.
Often
the cost goes up because people change their behavior to get free
stuff. A program meant to help the needy costs a certain amount. The
next year, it costs more, because now more of the needy know about the
program and more social workers know how to tap it. The next year, the
non-needy feel like suckers if they don’t get the handout, and they
figure out a way to game the system.
Then,
Mitchell point out, “what do politicians do the next year? They expand
the program to buy more votes. And the year after that, they add a new
benefit. That’s what’s happened with Medicare. It’s not just that they
got the fundamental estimates wrong. They did. But every new generation
of politicians figures out some new expansion, some new benefit.”
And so we’re on the road to Greece. Bottom line: Don’t trust the politicians’ numbers.
John Stossel is host of “Stossel” on the Fox Business Network. He’s the author of Give Me a Break and of Myth, Lies, and Downright Stupidity. © 2011 Creators.com